How to Write a College Essay That Sounds Like You (and Not AI)

How to Write a College Essay That Sounds Like You (and Not AI)

Introduction: Why Authenticity Wins
Colleges have seen thousands of essays about “leadership,” “passion,” and “resilience.” What stands out today isn’t a perfect essay; it’s a human one.
In the age of ChatGPT and AI-generated everything, admissions officers can spot a lifeless, over-polished essay instantly. What they’re craving are essays that sound personal, reflective, and real, essays that make them pause and think, “I know who this student is.”
Here’s how to write a college essay that sounds like you, not a robot, not a résumé, and not a thesaurus.
1. Start With a Moment, Not a Topic
Forget about choosing a “big” topic. The most powerful essays often begin with small, specific moments.
Instead of:
“I want to write about how moving to a new school taught me adaptability.”
Try:
“I still remember the sound of the cafeteria on my first day — hundreds of voices mixing together while I searched for an empty seat.”
Why it works: Specific details ground your story in reality. You’re not summarizing your life; you’re zooming in on one moment that shows who you are.
2. Don’t Sound Like a Dictionary
Admissions readers don’t want to see “ameliorate,” “cogitate,” or “synergy.” They want your voice.
Ask yourself:
  • Would I actually use this word in conversation?
  • Does this sentence sound like me, or like ChatGPT trying too hard?
Do this:
“I spent three months figuring out how to make a drone fly straight.”
Not this:
“Over a prolonged period, I endeavored to rectify the aerial imbalance of my mechanical prototype.”
Keep it simple. You’re writing for connection, not for a grammar competition.
3. Use Emotion, Not Perfection
AI essays are polished almost too polished. Human essays have rhythm, tone, and a heartbeat.
When revising, don’t edit out every imperfection. The small quirks of humor, uncertainty, and even vulnerability are what make your essay memorable.
Example:
“I failed my AP Bio exam. Twice. And honestly, it felt awful. But the second time, I realized failure didn’t mean I was bad at science just that I had to learn how to learn differently.”
That’s honesty, not weakness. Colleges admire self-awareness more than perfection.
4. Show Growth. Not a Summary of Achievements
Your essay isn’t a place to list awards. The Common App already has a section for that. Instead, show how you’ve changed. Growth is the heartbeat of a great essay.
Ask yourself:
  • What did this experience teach me about myself?
  • How am I different now than I was before?
Tip: If your essay ends the same way it started, it’s not about growth — it’s just a story.
5. Read It Out Loud (The Secret Test)
Here’s the simplest trick we teach at East Coast Admissions: read your essay out loud.
If it sounds robotic, formal, or like something you wouldn’t say to a friend or teacher, rewrite it. If it sounds natural and makes you smile or nod you’re close to your authentic voice.
Bonus check: have someone who knows you well read it and ask, “Does this sound like me?”
6. Use AI Wisely. Don’t Let It Write for You
AI can be a helpful brainstorming tool. It can help you outline ideas or rephrase sentences, but it should never replace your original voice.
Use AI to:
  • Generate potential essay prompts
  • Help organize structure
  • Spot grammar or clarity issues
Never use it to:
  • Write full paragraphs
  • Create emotional depth
  • Simulate personal reflection
Remember: AI can write about you, but it can’t write as you.
7. Final Gut Check: The “Best Friend” Rule
Before you submit, ask:
“If my best friend read this, would they say, ‘Yep, that’s totally you’?”
If yes, you’ve nailed it. If not, revise until your personality shines through.
Final Thoughts: Be Real, Be You
College admissions officers don’t want perfect essays. They want you: curious, thoughtful, imperfect, and real.
At East Coast Admissions, we’ve seen time and again that the essays that get remembered aren’t the ones with the biggest words; they’re the ones that sound like a genuine student reflecting on who they’re becoming.
Back to blog